Equity Compensation Planning
See our dedicated Equity Compensation Planning page →
Making the most out of your company stock options, stock grants, and restricted stock is one of the most complex financial challenges one will face. When should you exercise your stock options? What are the tax ramifications? How does the movement in your company stock impact your retirement?
We formulate a plan of action taking into consideration taxes and the potential gains of the underlying stock. We can create a comprehensive stock option analysis to determine exactly when to exercise based on the time value, tax treatment, exercise price, and intrinsic value.
Monetizing concentrated equity positions is also a challenge for those who have a significant portion of their net worth tied up in company stock and options. Financing stock options is an important strategy that is often overlooked.
Financing an option exercise: what it can do, and what it risks
Exercising options often requires cash for both the strike price and the resulting tax bill. Financing that exercise is one approach to consider. It is not the right approach for everyone, and the tradeoffs are real.
What it may make possible
- Covering the exercise cost and associated tax without selling shares
- Exercising ahead of an expiration date rather than at it
- Retaining exposure to the shares after exercise
- Access to liquidity without a same-day sale
- Retaining exercised shares if you leave the company
- In some fact patterns, a more favourable tax outcome from exercising earlier
Material risks and limitations
- Leverage cuts both ways. If the share price falls below your exercise price, you may owe more than the shares are worth.
- Borrowing has a cost. Interest accrues whether or not the stock appreciates, and can exceed any tax benefit.
- Recourse may extend beyond the shares. Depending on the structure, other assets may be pledged or at risk.
- ISO exercises can trigger alternative minimum tax in the year of exercise, even with no shares sold and no cash received.
- Concentration risk increases. Financing to hold shares increases exposure to a single company.
- Availability is not assured. Terms depend on the lender, the company, the security, and your circumstances.
- Company restrictions may apply. Insider trading policies, blackout windows, Rule 144 and pledging prohibitions can all limit or prevent this strategy.
The above is general education, not a recommendation. Whether an option-exercise financing strategy is appropriate depends entirely on your individual circumstances, including your tax position, liquidity, and your employer's equity plan and trading policies. Discuss any such strategy with your tax advisor and with us before acting.